The 41 Best Diners in Indianapolis To Visit in 2024 (2024)

The last thing that diners in Indianapolis are is far and few between, with it being the capital and most populous city in Indiana. With so many places to frequent and a large variety of foods on offer, where does one even start? Is it best to trust word-of-mouth from the locals, online reviews or the decorative awards from renowned cuisine organizations when deciding which diners in Indianapolis to visit?

With so many options, why not try them all? Luckily, we have compiled a list of the 41 top Diners in Indianapolis to give you, your friends and your family a starting point for casual brunches, celebratory dinners and everything in between.

Jump to Section

  • The 41 Best Diners in Indianapolis
  • Learn To Cook the Best Indianapolis Foods
Top-Rated Cooking Classes in Indianapolis Master the art of gourmet cuisine with the help of the best chefs in Indianapolis. Book Now

The 41 Best Diners in Indianapolis

1. South Side Soda Shop

Owned by a lovely married couple, South Side Soda Shop is a small diner in Indianapolis that has very quickly become a favorite for many people.

The Vibe

A classic, old-school diner that makes you feel like you've traveled back in time. The exterior sports a shiny metallic lining on the corners and rim of the roof. The interior has classic diner booths and laminated tables.

What to Order

Choose from a variety of different old and new diner meal options, including salads, sandwiches and delectable desserts.

South Side Soda Shop | 1122 S. Main St., Goshen, IN 46526 | $$

The 41 Best Diners in Indianapolis To Visit in 2024 (1)

2. 10th Street Diner

Whether or not you're vegan, you'll love 10th Street Diner. This diner in Indianapolis with a menu made up entirely of vegan and vegetarian-friendly options that everyone can enjoy serves some of the best breakfast in Indianapolis.

The Vibe

Modern with a friendly and welcoming atmosphere. The ceiling is made up of wooden beams with a gap between each that is visually appealing, the walls are beautiful exposed brick and "10th Street Diner" is written in large metallic 3D letters hung on one of the walls.

What to Order

This diner in Indianapolis offers a variety of delicious foods such as the vegan Reuben sandwich and the Submarine sandwich.

10th Street Diner | 3301 E. 10th St., Indianapolis, IN 46201 | $$

3. The Cake Bake Shop

Visit The Cake Bake Shop for an escape from the ordinary. A unique diner in Indianapolis that transports you to a French fairytale cottage, you can indulge in a variety of sweet treats and baked goods here.

The Vibe

With gorgeous seasonal floral arrangements, antiqued mirrors, sparkling chandeliers and French-inspired furniture, you'll feel like you're in a French fairytale.

What to Order

Indulge your senses with a food experience like no other. Try the famous quiche, a homemade soup or one of the many mouthwatering cakes. Eating at this unique diner in Indianapolis is a sweet treat escape that makes for a romantic date idea in Indianapolis.

The Cake Bake Shop | 6515 Carrollton Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46220 | $$

The 41 Best Diners in Indianapolis To Visit in 2024 (2)

4. Ale Emporium

Pop into Ale Emporium, a family-run sports pub and restaurant that focuses on providing local beers and food made with only the freshest ingredients. Open since 1982, Ale Emporium is a local landmark in Indianapolis.

The Vibe

A friendly and spacious diner in Indianapolis with a sports bar vibe. Ale Emporium is the perfect spot to enjoy delicious food, beer and great company.

What to Order

This diner in Indianapolis is best known for its famous Hermanaki wings and mouth-watering deep-dish pizza. Along with delicious food, you can order a wide variety of local and popular beers that hit the spot.

Ale Emporium | 8617 Allisonville Road, Indianapolis, IN 46250 | $$

Top-Rated Cooking Classes in Indianapolis Master the art of gourmet cuisine with the help of the best chefs in Indianapolis. Book Now

5. Rize

Located inside the Ironworks Hotel, Rize is a diner in Indianapolis that's also accessible to the public and is well worth a visit.

The Vibe

This popular spot mirrors the aesthetic of the upscale hotel it's located in while providing an enjoyable and comfortable experience.

What to Order

The food at this diner in Indianapolis is fresh and creative. The menu offers a wide variety of meals that everyone can enjoy. The chia bowl is an absolute must-try for breakfast.

Rize | 2721 E. 86th St., Ste. 120, Indianapolis, IN 46240 | $$

The 41 Best Diners in Indianapolis To Visit in 2024 (3)

6. Ripple Bagel and Deli

A small diner in Indianapolis that packs a mighty culinary punch, Ripple Bagel and Deli offers delicious freshly-made sandwiches, bagels and more.

The Vibe

A wall of blackboards lists all the sandwiches made here, giving it a New York deli feel. The staff are friendly and knowledgeable about the available products.

What to Order

The sandwiches all have unique names that give this diner in Indianapolis its personality. Choose from one of the many established choices or add your unique twist by ordering a custom sandwich or bagel. If you aren’t in the mood for bread, try one of the fresh soups or salads.

Ripple Bagel and Deli | 850 Broad Ripple Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46220 | $

7. Fat Dan's Deli

Set in a pub and deli-style diner, Fat Dan’s Deli is a diner in Indianapolis that offers a variety of Chicago-style comfort foods.

The Vibe

A cheery atmosphere makes it the perfect venue for an evening out to watch sports and enjoy a drink with friends or family.

What to Order

Described as “smokin’ good Chicago comfort food,” this diner in Indianapolis will not disappoint those looking for a taste of Chicago. Enjoy hot dogs, hearty burgers and unbeatable pizzas.

Fat Dan’s Deli | 5410 N. College Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46220 | $$

The 41 Best Diners in Indianapolis To Visit in 2024 (4)

8. Root & Bone

Pop into Root & Bone to experience a beautifully decorated diner in Indianapolis serving delicious meals made by a James Beard-nominated chef.

The Vibe

A rustic and chic diner in Indianapolis with exposed brick walls, mosaic tiles on a hanging ceiling above the bar/serving counter and country-style dining tables to finish off the Southern aesthetic.

What to Order

Some of the favorites include deviled eggs, corn soufflé, ribs, waffles and fried chicken.

Root & Bone | 4601 N. College Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46205 | $$

Top-Rated Cooking Classes in Indianapolis Master the art of gourmet cuisine with the help of the best chefs in Indianapolis. Book Now

9. His Place Eatery

A Cajun and Creole-style diner in Indianapolis owned by Chef James Jones and his wife, Shawn Marie Jones, the philosophy at His Place Eatery is that soul food can be served uniquely and with flair.

The Vibe

A hidden gem of a diner in Indianapolis with great service and even better food. The décor is simplistic and gives a real homely vibe.

What to Order

The chicken and waffles are superb, the smoked ribs are juicy and delicious and the Memphis pulled pork is a truly filling dish. Each meal served at this diner in Indianapolis is unique and tasty.

His Place Eatery | 6916 E. 30th St., Indianapolis, IN 46219 | $$

The 41 Best Diners in Indianapolis To Visit in 2024 (5)

10. Long's Bakery

If you're craving something sweet for breakfast or want a satisfying treat to end your night, Long’s Bakery has you covered. Opened in January 1955, it has long since been a top-rated diner in Indianapolis, even earning itself the "#1 bakery in Indianapolis" accolade on TripAdvisor.

The Vibe

A quaint, traditional bakery layout with display counters where customers can view and pick what they want. A gap in the wall between the serving area and the kitchen allows customers to catch a glimpse of what the talented chefs are baking.

What to Order

Long’s Bakery offers various doughnuts, pies, strudels, brownies and cakes. The most popular picks are the different varieties of doughnuts available.

Long’s Bakery | 1453 N. Tremont St., Indianapolis, IN 46222 | $

11. King Dough

What started as a food truck in 2014 and has now turned into a popular pizza-orientated diner in Indianapolis. The goal at King Dough has always been to champion the craft of pizza making.

The Vibe

Expect a mix between a traditional pizzeria and a pizza party atmosphere. The staff are friendly and helpful, always ready to answer any questions.

What to Order

Always focused on maintaining the perfect pizzeria, King Dough uses the freshest and highest-quality ingredients to make a range of pizzas, from classic to unique. Your pizza can be made vegetarian, vegan, gluten-free or classic.

King Dough | 452 N. Highland Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46202 | $$

The 41 Best Diners in Indianapolis To Visit in 2024 (6)

12. The Eagle

When dining at The Eagle, you'll be presented with the straightforward American fare and classic comfort food on which this diner in Indianapolis prides itself.

The Vibe

Exposed brick walls, rustic timber roofing and tables, and warm lighting give this diner a casual hipster vibe. A black-and-white mural of a large eagle adorns one of the brick walls.

What to Order

The Eagle offers a wide range of different alcoholic beverages, with 16 taps for local, craft and domestic beers, plus 100 different bottles and cans of various brews. To eat, a popular recommendation is the fried chicken, which is brined and dredged in-house.

The Eagle | 310 Massachusetts Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46204 | $$

Top-Rated Cooking Classes in Indianapolis Master the art of gourmet cuisine with the help of the best chefs in Indianapolis. Book Now

13. Prime 47

For some of the best USDA prime beef, among a range of delicious upscale meals, visit Prime 47, a high-end steakhouse and seafood diner in Indianapolis.

The Vibe

A classy steakhouse with a stunning and eye-catching interior. The large windows give you a stunning view out into Indianapolis while the lighting is a warm yellow-white, presenting a relaxed, romantic vibe.

What to Order

You can't go wrong with the filet mignon for a delicious steak dinner. If you feel like a high-end seafood meal, order the lobster bisque, made with the freshest and best-quality ingredients.

Prime 47 | 47 S. Pennsylvania St., Indianapolis, IN 46204 | $$$

The 41 Best Diners in Indianapolis To Visit in 2024 (7)

14. Milktooth

Established in 2014 by chef Jonathan Brooks and his wife Ashley, Milktooth is a fine diner in Indianapolis built on passion and a commitment to fresh, quality ingredients.

The Vibe

Simplistic and cozy with a country farm-style setting — a comfortable and relaxing atmosphere to enjoy an unconventionally creative breakfast.

What to Order

Enjoy various delectable breakfast and brunch foods, including local berry Dutch baby pancake, sorghum glazed bacon and the pecan sticky bun.

Milktooth | 534 Virginia Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46203 | $$

15. St. Elmo Steak House

The capital of Indiana is filled with a variety of top-rated steak houses, and that includes St. Elmo Steak House, a high-end diner in Indianapolis that's also known for its seafood and co*cktails.

The Vibe

Step into a dim, warmly lit dining hall with old-school pictures lining the walls. A stunning dark-wood cellar holds hundreds of bottles of wine, all with exceptional flavors. Upstairs, there is a 1933 speakeasy-styled lounge for patrons to enjoy.

What to Order

St. Elmo Steak House is famous for its delicious, mouth-wateringly famous shrimp co*cktails. If you aren’t into fish, you'll find delectable and flavorful steaks in different styles.

St. Elmo Steak House | 127 S. Illinois St., Indianapolis, IN 46225 | $$$

The 41 Best Diners in Indianapolis To Visit in 2024 (8)

16. Bluebeard

Established in 2012, Bluebeard is a New American-cuisine restaurant located in the historic Holy Rosary neighborhood of downtown Indianapolis.

The Vibe

The rustic interior features light-wood tables, old-school shelves with sliding ladders, a country-style bar counter and a rustic iron chandelier.

What to Order

Bluebeard serves delectable, farm-to-table meals, including fresh and delicious duck confit salad and a tasty skirt steak.

Bluebeard | 653 Virginia Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46203 | $$$

Top-Rated Cooking Classes in Indianapolis Master the art of gourmet cuisine with the help of the best chefs in Indianapolis. Book Now

17. Vida

Mike Cunningham of the Cunningham Restaurant Group opened Vida in 2016, and it has since earned multiple awards, including being the first and only diner in Indianapolis to earn the coveted "AAA Four Diamond" award.

The Vibe

Culinary techniques with diverse world influences give off a modern expression wrapped up in a relaxed and stunning ambiance.

What to Order

Vida's food is made with only the best and freshest ingredients to provide a unique and truly memorable experience. For a melt-in-your-mouth steak, order the Strube ranch wagyu ribeye.

Vida | 601 E. New York St., Indianapolis, IN 46202 | $$$$

The 41 Best Diners in Indianapolis To Visit in 2024 (9)

18. The Rathskeller

Originally established in 1894 under the name Das Deutsche Haus (The German House), the first section of the Athenaeum only contained The Rathskeller and the gymnasium. In 1898, the Athenaeum took on its present form with the addition of the cabaret-style theater and the Kellesaal.

The Vibe

Step inside and get transported to a traditional German beer garden. Take in German Renaissance architecture, with slated roofing, leaded glass windows and magnificent woodwork. Admire the cabaret-style theater, concert hall and ballroom where you can enjoy live music and dancing, Wednesday through Saturday.

What to Order

This diner in Indianapolis serves traditional and authentic German cuisine and beers. For main meals, it has foods such as schnitzel and sauerbraten. For dessert, enjoy black forest cake, German chocolate cheesecake and much more.

The Rathskeller | 401 E. Michigan St., Indianapolis, IN 46204 | $$

19. Steer-In

Founded way back in 1957, Steer-In was a hit during the drive-in boom. To this day, it is still a must-try diner in Indianapolis.

The Vibe

A historic, old-school drive-in setting with a comfortable and nostalgic atmosphere, the restaurant offers excellent service. The friendly staff is always on hand and happy to help.

What to Order

The Steer-In became popular for its Twin Steer burger. Now, you can get a variety of tasty meals, such as Hoosier tenderloin and delicious pancakes. You know the food is good when Guy Fieri himself certifies it.

Steer-In | 5130 E. 10th St., Indianapolis, IN 46219 | $$

The 41 Best Diners in Indianapolis To Visit in 2024 (10)

20. Tinker Street

Established in 2014 with its name as a nod to the original name of 16th Street, Tinker Street is a wine and New American-cuisine diner in Indianapolis that definitely won't disappoint.

The Vibe

It has a cozy, urban cottage setting with a casual and relaxing atmosphere. To enter, you must be 21 or older and have a valid photo ID.

What to Order

Enjoy an array of fresh plant-based, vegetarian and vegan dishes, such as delicious pad Thai or Korean fried mushrooms, with a selection of high-quality international wines. Meat eaters can enjoy foods such as the filling pork belly.

Tinker Street Restaurant | 402 E. 16th St., Indianapolis, IN 46202 | $$$

Top-Rated Cooking Classes in Indianapolis Master the art of gourmet cuisine with the help of the best chefs in Indianapolis. Book Now

21. Good Morning Mama’s

As the name implies and unlike 24-hour diners in Indianapolis, Good Morning Mama’s is a diner in Indianapolis that focuses on breakfast and brunch.

The Vibe

As you approach this beloved spot, you will see the beautifully and brightly painted exterior walls, which feature a mural of a bird singing on a branch and the text "Good Morning Mama’s Café" above and below the bird. The interior is painted and decorated with bold and bright yellow.

What to Order

Serving all sorts of traditional and not-so-traditional breakfasts such as eggs Benedict and Java French toast, you are sure to find something you will enjoy at this diner in Indianapolis.

Good Morning Mama’s | 1001 E. 54th St., Indianapolis, IN 46220 | $$

The 41 Best Diners in Indianapolis To Visit in 2024 (11)

22. Tony's of Indianapolis

If you're on the lookout for an upscale, high-end American steakhouse and seafood diner in Indianapolis, Tony’s of Indianapolis is a must-visit. TripAdvisor rates it as one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis, and with good reason.

The Vibe

Exposed brick walls, polished dark-wood floors and raised wooden-beam ceilings set this diner in Indianapolis apart.

What to Order

Indulge in a variety of expertly prepared meals made with love and attention, like the braised short ribs.

Tony’s of Indianapolis | 110 W. Washington St., Indianapolis, IN 46204 | $$$$

23. The Workingman’s Friend

Happily serving locals and visitors from far and wide aged 21 years and up, The Workingman’s Friend is a diner in Indianapolis where the charming atmosphere is trumped only by the delectable food.

The Vibe

Quaint, with a traditional diner aesthetic. It has a simple layout — a bar counter with high stools to sit and drink or eat at, plus tables and red-cushioned chairs dotted around the dining hall.

What to Order

This diner is famous for its range of burgers. It's definitely worth trying the double cheeseburger or the smash burger with crispy fries.

The Workingman’s Friend | 234 N. Belmont Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46222 | $$

The 41 Best Diners in Indianapolis To Visit in 2024 (12)

24. Metro Diner

Established in 1992, Metro Diner has happily served its guests diner classics alongside new and innovative dishes for 32 years.

The Vibe

A diner in Indianapolis that strives to provide a warm and homey environment for its guests to enjoy and relax in while eating fresh and creative diner classics.

What to Order

This diner in Indianapolis serves a range of classic and new creative breakfast and brunch dishes, including huevos rancheros, chicken pot pie and Belgian waffles.

Metro Diner | 3954 E. 82nd St., Indianapolis, IN 46240 | $$

Top-Rated Cooking Classes in Indianapolis Master the art of gourmet cuisine with the help of the best chefs in Indianapolis. Book Now

25. John’s Famous Stew

Established in 1911, John’s Famous Stew is a diner in Indianapolis that has been supporting and providing food for blue-collar workers throughout the decades.

The Vibe

The interior of this diner is simplistic, with a few old-school photos, military pictures and neon signs decorating the walls. The staff are friendly and make you feel right at home.

What to Order

As the name implies, this diner in Indianapolis is famous for its affordable stew, made using the same recipe since its inception. The most popular dishes available are the John Stew burger, John's famous tenderloin supreme and the giant breaded tenderloin sandwich.

John’s Famous Stew | 1146 Kentucky Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46221 | $$

The 41 Best Diners in Indianapolis To Visit in 2024 (13)

26. GoldLeaf Savory & Sweet

If you're always on the go, GoldLead Savory & Sweet is the place to pop into. This hipster diner in Indianapolis offers quick bites to eat with coffee in the mornings and wraps, sandwiches and salads during lunch hours.

The Vibe

A relaxing, homey vibe with plants of all kinds decorating the building.

What to Order

Take in the greenery while enjoying a breakfast burrito, breakfast sandwich or a house-made chicken salad.

GoldLeaf Savory & Sweet | 1901 E. 46th St., Ste 1., Indianapolis, IN 46205 | $

27. Yolk - City Way

First established in 2006 in Chicago, Yolk - City Way has since opened multiple locations, including a diner in Indianapolis that should be your next place to visit.

The Vibe

Contrasting yellow and blue painted walls bring a unique vibrance to this diner. The ceiling is tiled in glossy white and blue, with lights shining from each white space.

What to Order

The pancakes served at this diner in Indianapolis are heavenly. You can expect a pancake with a specific theme for each new month, and what better way to eat them than with a coffee that is made using the freshest local grinds?

Yolk - City Way | 220 E. South St., Indianapolis, IN 46204 | $$

The 41 Best Diners in Indianapolis To Visit in 2024 (14)

28. Rock-Cola 50's Café

Established in 1992 and owned by head chef, Greg Codozor, Rock-Cola 50’s Café is a diner in Indianapolis that promises enjoyment.

The Vibe

Travel back in time to the 1950s when stepping into this diner in Indianapolis, which stays true to the aesthetics and vibe of the era.

What to Order

The favorites at this spot are the fresh, large sandwiches such as the Mile-High Clubs, Reubens and Philly cheesesteaks.

Rock-Cola 50’s Café | 5730 Brookville Road, Indianapolis, IN 46219 | $$

Top-Rated Cooking Classes in Indianapolis Master the art of gourmet cuisine with the help of the best chefs in Indianapolis. Book Now

29. Four Seasons Diner

Perfect for family gatherings or large group get-togethers, Four Seasons Diner is a Mediterranean and American diner in Indianapolis.

The Vibe

A casual diner in Indianapolis with a warm, cozy, homey atmosphere. The staff makes you feel at home as you step through the doors.

What to Order

Expect a choice of many Mediterranean and American meals at this diner in Indianapolis — the three most popular dishes being French toast, country fried steak with two eggs and a classic eggs Benedict.

Four Seasons Diner | 1935 N. Shadeland Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46219 | $

The 41 Best Diners in Indianapolis To Visit in 2024 (15)

30. Ali'i Poke

If you're in the mood for a Hawaiian-style poke diner in Indianapolis, Ali’i Poke is the place to be. It was established in 2018 and has since become a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

The Vibe

Enjoy a simple interior with minimal décor. A collage of Hawaiian locations and foods in a dark-bordered frame decorates the one wall for all to marvel.

What to Order

A variety of seafood poke bowls are served at this diner in Indianapolis using fresh ingredients, including the spicy tuna, seaweed salad and marinated salmon.

Ali’i Poke| 910 W. 10th St., Indianapolis, IN 46202 | $$

31. FortyFive Degrees

For fresh sushi at an affordable price, pop into FortyFive Degrees, a sushi bar and diner in Indianapolis with an upscale setting.

The Vibe

Soft neon lights shining upon modern seating and tables give this sushi bar a lively and trendy atmosphere, so much so that you'll wish it was a 24-hour diner in Indianapolis for those post-party food cravings.

What to Order

Traditional and new creative variations of sushi made with fresh and flavorful ingredients give you a variety of options to choose from, including the Playboy roll, Mount Fuji roll and The 45° Salad.

FortyFive Degrees | 765 Massachusetts Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46204 | $$

The 41 Best Diners in Indianapolis To Visit in 2024 (16)

32. Siam Square

Thai diners in Indianapolis don't get any better than Siam Square. Opened in 2008 in a building that was used as a German grocery store in 1885, Chef Chutikan Souvannachack shares her Bangkok roots in the delightful food served here.

The Vibe

Feel relaxed inside the green-walled dining area with Thai-inspired décor.

What to Order

Start your meal with the fresh Siam roll before enjoying a flavorful green curry or a catfish filet.

Siam Square | 936 Virginia Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46203 | $$

Top-Rated Cooking Classes in Indianapolis Master the art of gourmet cuisine with the help of the best chefs in Indianapolis. Book Now

33. Kabuto Japanese Steakhouse

A well-known diner in Indianapolis for some, yet still a hidden gem for others, you need to try Kabuto Japanese Steakhouse for yourself. You'll be spoiled for choice with plenty of options, from perfectly grilled meats to freshly prepared seafood.

The Vibe

Kabuto is the perfect diner in Indianapolis for your next date night. The dark furniture and walls, combined with the warm lights, create an intimate dining experience.

What to Order

While there are many delicious items on the menu, the Kabuto special is a must-try. Choose between the lobster, scallop or filet mignon paired with a fresh salad. If you're in the mood for sushi instead, try the array of options available.

Kabuto Japanese Steakhouse | 8719 U.S. Highway 31 S., Indianapolis, IN 46227 | $$

The 41 Best Diners in Indianapolis To Visit in 2024 (17)

34. Hinata Japanese Fine Dining

Opened by Nobu Nakajima, a highly experienced Japanese chef with 23 years of experience, Hinata Japanese Fine Dining is a high-end diner in Indianapolis.

The Vibe

Dine in a sophisticated and contemporary atmosphere with an open sushi bar, where you can watch as your seafood dish is prepared before your eyes.

What to Order

While the menu is updated every month, some favorites you should try are the sashimi course, the Japanese snow crab and the sweet potato pâté.

Hinata Japanese Fine Dining | 130 E. Washington St., Indianapolis, IN 46204 | $$

35. Yats

Experience New Orleans cuisine as it should be at this diner in Indianapolis. With locations scattered across the Midwest, Yats is a Creole and Cajun diner, opened by Joe Vuskovich, that reflects his roots.

The Vibe

Across the many locations, Yats offers a funky and vibrant place for diners to relax and enjoy mouthwatering food. The bright red walls and creative décor make this diner in Indianapolis unique.

What to Order

Yats has a rotating menu to keep things exciting. One classic is jambalaya, a Creole dish of rice with chicken and sausage. Vegans should try the white chili.

Yats | Multiple Locations | $$

The 41 Best Diners in Indianapolis To Visit in 2024 (18)

36. La Margarita

Located in the heart of the popular Fountain Square is one of the best Mexican diners in Indianapolis. Since 1984, La Margarita has been serving authentic Mexican food to locals who can't get enough of it.

The Vibe

A modern and vibrant restaurant with a bar that boasts an impressive variety of tequila. The bold murals and bright décor keep things exciting.

What to Order

The most-ordered meals on the menu are the burritos and tacos. With so many choices, narrowing down one is hard, but the birria taco meal will hit the spot with slow-cooked beef, rice, salsa and cilantro.

La Margarita | 1043 Virginia Ave., Ste. 1., Indianapolis, IN 46203 | $$

Top-Rated Cooking Classes in Indianapolis Master the art of gourmet cuisine with the help of the best chefs in Indianapolis. Book Now

37. Paco’s Taqueria

Visit Paco’s Taqueria, an authentic Mexican-cuisine diner in Indianapolis that serves delicious breakfast, lunch and dinner.

The Vibe

Bright murals and a focus on serving outstanding Mexican food that will keep you coming back for more are the standard across all locations.

What to Order

A trip to Paco’s is not complete without digging into one of the delicious tacos — more specifically, the chorizo sausage taco. For something different, order the ramen birria, which is a classic birria served with ramen noodles.

Paco’s Taqueria | Multiple Locations | $$

The 41 Best Diners in Indianapolis To Visit in 2024 (19)

38. Chapati

Immerse yourself in traditional Pakistani, Indian and Middle Eastern cuisine in this popular diner in Indianapolis called Chapati. Among other reasons, it's a popular spot because its recipes are slow-cooked and made with the freshest ingredients.

The Vibe

Bright and vibrant with exciting décor representing Indian, Middle Eastern and Pakistani cultures. The bright blue walls are warm and inviting, making it a great place to catch up with friends.

What to Order

You can’t go wrong with a classic like the creamy chicken tikka masala, which is marinated for 24 hours until reaching a melt-in-your-mouth tenderness. For vegetarian and halal diners, there are plenty of options — one such favorite being the eggplant masala.

Chapati | 4930 Lafayette Road, Ste. G, Indianapolis, IN 46254 | $$

39. Convivio Italian Artisan Cuisine

Looking for a diner in Indianapolis that serves inspired and authentic Italian pasta? Pop into Convivio Italian Artisan Cuisine, an intimate and innovative Italian pasta shop opened by Andrea Melani and Emilio Cento.

The Vibe

Elegance and class welcome you in with aged-wood panel walls and cream linen. Admire the artwork lining the walls while enjoying a delicious meal with friends or family.

What to Order

The tentacolo di polpo is a popular pasta dish that combines grilled octopus and goat cheese with a rich balsamic glaze. Leave room for dessert because the tiramisu is a must-have.

ConvivioItalian Artisan Cuisine | 11529 Spring Mill Road, Ste. 250, Carmel, IN 46032 | $$

The 41 Best Diners in Indianapolis To Visit in 2024 (20)

40. Sangiovese Ristorante

Enjoy delicious Italian food in the heart of Indianapolis at Sangiovese Ristorante. This upscale, locally beloved diner in Indianapolis is popular for its delicious and classic Italian cuisine and coffee.

The Vibe

The dark walls and furniture stand out against the low-hanging white lights, giving the room a cozy and modern atmosphere perfect for date nights.

What to Order

Pasta lovers will enjoy the linguine served with sautéed baby clams doused in a spicy white wine butter sauce. Speaking of wine, pair your meal with one of the fine wines available from the extensive list.

Sangiovese Ristorante | 2727 E. 86th St., Ste. 110, Indianapolis, IN 46240 | $$

41. Petite Chou Bistro and Champagne Bar

Opened in 2007 by six-time James Beard Foundation semifinalist, Martha Hoover, Petite Chou Bistro and Champagne Bar is one of the most upscale diners in Indianapolis.

The Vibe

Step inside and get transported to a quaint bistro in France. The warm and cozy room, with its pink walls and cane furniture, is typically French.

What to Order

You simply cannot visit a French restaurant without enjoying the classic crêpes topped with fresh berries or the irresistible Nutella option. For a savory option, the duck fat pommes frites are a popular meal.

Petite Chou Bistro and Champagne Bar | 823 Westfield Blvd., Indianapolis, IN 46220 | $$

The 41 Best Diners in Indianapolis To Visit in 2024 (21)

Learn To Cook the Best Indianapolis Foods

With so many choices available, picking just one diner in Indianapolis can often be overwhelming. Fortunately, there’s another way to enjoy the food inspired by the top-rated diners in the city. Learn how to cook your favorite foods at home thanks to a variety of cooking classes in Indianapolis. With the help of an experienced chef, you can master the skills needed to cook your favorite foods and learn several new tricks along the way. Secure your spot today and become the cook you've always dreamed of being.

Indianapolis is a melting pot of culture and the incredible flavors of food that come with them. It's a place where you can satisfy your craving for a classic American burger as easily as you can immerse yourself in the culinary traditions of the Greater Middle East.

Whatever you fancy, hopefully this list of the 41 best diners in Indianapolis has inspired you to make the most of your culinary adventure. Whether French bistro dining is your idea of foodie heaven, or you're craving classic American fare, there is definitely a diner here for you.

The 41 Best Diners in Indianapolis To Visit in 2024 (22) Join 200,000+ Culinary Enthusiasts

Exclusive deals, recipes, cookbooks, and our best tips for home cooks — free and straight to your inbox. PLUS: 500 Rewards Points.

YOU'RE IN!

Thank you for signing up for our mailing list.

For even more ways to explore Indianapolis and beyond, check out other experiences happening on Cozymeal.

The 41 Best Diners in Indianapolis To Visit in 2024 (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Twana Towne Ret

Last Updated:

Views: 5847

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (64 voted)

Reviews: 87% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Twana Towne Ret

Birthday: 1994-03-19

Address: Apt. 990 97439 Corwin Motorway, Port Eliseoburgh, NM 99144-2618

Phone: +5958753152963

Job: National Specialist

Hobby: Kayaking, Photography, Skydiving, Embroidery, Leather crafting, Orienteering, Cooking

Introduction: My name is Twana Towne Ret, I am a famous, talented, joyous, perfect, powerful, inquisitive, lovely person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.